Smitty’s All American Grill

Reviews

• Courtney M.

  star star star star star_border 1 June 2026

  This was a find via open table. Honestly the food was pretty good and the atmosphere was very laid back. Our server was extremely nice and he was happy to be working. Those of the type of people that you want in your restaurant. Overall the experience was enjoyable and I would recommend a friend in Mattituck to go to this casual food location.

• JayDee P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  None of the food really stood out. I ordered the sirloin steak over fingerling potatoes and zucchini. I asked for the sauce to be put on the side, instead they gave me a cup with extra sauce AND on my steak. The service was extremely slow. The bartender was our waiter and he was preoccupied with the bar the whole time (makes sense).
  
  I had to ask another waiter for extra beverages and the last time I had to physically walk up to the bar for another drink and to get the check.
  
  We came here on a Tuesday night about 7PM. It wasn't particularly crowded at all.
  
  Overall I wasn't impressed.

• Tara K.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 25 May 2026

  If I could give this place 0 stars, I would. We walked in for a table of 4 to a fairly empty restaurant and were not even acknowledged. After waiting a good 5 minutes, someone approached us and sat us at a table with menus. Waited another 10 minutes just to have our drink order taken. Drinks arrived and we were assured he would be back in a minute for our order - that never happened. We sat there waiting for about 20 minutes, watching everyone around us, who arrived after us, have their order taken. Again, pretty empty restaurant and a good 5 waiters walking around aimlessly. Waited another 10 minutes, got disgusted, dropped money on the table and left. Nobody even cared as we got up and walked out. But we ended up at an amazing restaurant with great service, so thank you.

• Britni M.

  star star star star star 23 May 2026

  The place itself is pretty big and uniquely set up by having 3 levels of the dining area. They have pool, arcades and a bowling alley that look very cool and I can see how this place could get packed in the summertime. They food was great and they have a lot of tv's sets up which is good if you're sports fan. Definitely coming back here again.

• James B.

  star star star star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  This is a bar/grill attached to a bowling alley.  Interesting stadium seating layout.  Service was ok.  Ordered the ribs, and they were kind of chewy, which means that they were either a lower quality rib, or overcooked.  The fries were good, but the ribs kind of ruined it for me.  This place is "average" at best, and best to stick with bar food like burgers and fries.  I would not recommend coming here specifically for a dinner out.  A generous 3 stars.